10 Most Costly Homeowner's Insurance Myths (2024)

If you’re one of the two-thirds of Americans who own a home, chances are you have homeowner’s insurance. As one of the most common kinds of insurance it’s the subject of more myths than others.

Mistakenly basing your decisions on them can put your home at risk. These costly misconceptions cost unsuspecting homeowners hundreds of millions of dollars a year.

We’ve compiled a list of 10 of the most costly homeowner’s insurance myths to help you steer clear of trouble:

1. Everyone I hire to work around my home is covered

It’s true that some people you hire to work around your home are covered under the personal property portion of your policy. Housekeepers, babysitters, and pet sitters are covered by your homeowner’s insurance if they are hurt while working for you.

Contractors, such as plumbers, carpenters and electricians are not covered by your homeowner’s insurance. This includes unlicensed part-time handymen doing minor repairs. The best practice is to ask for a current certificate of insurance from any contractor or handyman before they start work.

2. Homeowner’s insurance rate will go up if I file a claim

It’s possible, but not likely that your insurance company will increase your homeowner’s insurance premium if file a claim. Rate increases are based on your claim history over time rather than on a single incident. So chances are filing a single claim every few years is not going to cause an increase. However, regularly filing small claims can cause an insurer to take a look at your premium and ask for an increase.

Every insurance company has its own internal criteria that trigger increases. There are some things you can do to reduce that possibility.

Before you file a claim think about your deductible. If the amount of your claim will only be for a small amount more than your deductible consider paying for it yourself. The few extra dollars you spend now may save you more over the next few years of paying a higher rate.

3. Mold is always covered by homeowner’s insurance

The exact opposite is true; mold is almost never covered. This is because mold is usually the result of a lack of proper maintenance.

A a leaky pipe that causes mold to grow inside a wall is not covered. Insurance companies expect you to keep your home in good repair, which includes fixing leaks. For mold to be covered you must prove that it is because of an insured peril.

4. All of my belongings are covered

The personal property portion of your homeowner’s insurance policy will have several limits you should be aware of. The first is the total amount they will reimburse you for if everything in your home is destroyed or stolen.

There are also individual limits for valuables such as jewelry and art. On a standard policy, these limits can be as low as $1,500. Separate endorsem*nts can be added to increase your limits for jewelry, art, and other valuables. You may want to consider raising your total coverage for all of your possessions. This is especially true if you have very expensive furnishings and clothes.

5. Mortgage banker will make sure I have enough

This is a very dangerous myth that comes from the belief that the bank that holds your mortgage wants to protect your home as much as you do. This is not true. The only portion of your home’s value that your mortgage banker is concerned with is the amount you owe them.

Your personal property and the current value of your home don’t matter to your bank. The bank’s only concern is that you have enough coverage to pay off your outstanding mortgage balance. The only person who is cares if you have enough homeowner’s insurance is you.

6. Water and flood damage are the same thing

While flood damage is always the result of water, water damage is not always the result of flooding. That is an important difference.

For insurance purposes, water damage is caused by water before it hits the ground. For example, a burst pipe or rain that comes in through a storm damaged roof is covered. However, once the water hits the ground, it causes flood damage and is not covered. This includes storm runoff, overflowing streams, rivers or lakes and tidal storm surge.

Another myth is that your home is only in danger of flooding if you live close to the ocean, a river, or other large body of water. This is also not true.

You can check your home’s flood risk online. The National Flood Insurance Program lets you enter your address and find out what your flood risk is. Since flooding is not covered by homeowner’s insurance the government does far less than you might expect.

7. I don’t need a home inventory

There are two reasons you should have an updated home inventory: Making sure you have enough coverage, and to file a claim.

A home inventory will enable you to have an accurate record of your belongings. It will also allow you to total up their value. You will then be able to make sure the contents portion of your policy is high enough.

A home inventory may be necessary if your home is damaged or burglarized. Some insurance company will want to know exactly what was lost before they issue a check and a home inventory makes that simple.

8. My home-based business is covered

Owning and operating a business from home has become very popular in recent years. Even though you own your business along with its furniture and equipment, it isn’t considered personal property. That means it isn’t covered by your homeowner’s insurance policy if it’s damaged or stolen.

Some insurance companies allow you to add a rider to cover your home business’ furniture and equipment. You must apply this coverage and pay the added premium.

A popular sub-myth is that you if you don’t tell the insurance company about the business, they won’t know. This is also not true. The result if found out is that you will have committed fraud and your entire claim may be denied.

9. I’m protected against termites and other pests

Your homeowner’s insurance policy will not pay for damage caused by termites, mice, rats, and other pests. Keeping your home free of insects and other pests is considered routine maintenance. The damage that is caused by these home invaders is viewed as neglect by you.

Whether it’s a termite infestation that destroys your porch or rodents that gnaw though your electrical panel you are responsible. The cost of repairing damage is your responsibility.

10. Hotel expenses are always covered

If you’re unable to live in your home while repairs are being made, your insurance may not pay for your hotelmotel room. On the other hand, some policies will reimburse you for all or a portion of your living expenses while your home is being repaired.

You should read your policy carefully looking for a loss of use provision. If it is not expressly listed as a covered expense it is not covered. If you do have loss of use protection there may also be limitations on the amount and duration of reimbursem*nt.

10 Most Costly Homeowner's Insurance Myths (2024)

FAQs

What are the most costly homeowners claims? ›

#1. Fire and Lightning. From 2014–2018, fire and lightning accounted for the costliest claims, with an average claim of $79,785. About one in every 350 insured homes had fire and lightning damage.

Who is the most expensive homeowners insurance? ›

Travelers is the most expensive homeowners insurance company for $200,000, $350,000, $500,000 and $750,000 dwelling coverage amounts. Rates vary significantly among companies because they each have their own formulas for pricing. That means it's vital to comparison shop homeowners insurance quotes when buying a policy.

Why is homeowners insurance so expensive? ›

Why homeowners insurance rates are rising. Several factors are making homeowners insurance more expensive: The increase in the number and severity of hurricanes, floods, tornadoes and other harsh weather has led to a spike in claims in many parts of the country.

What are the 3 biggest factors in determining the cost for homeowners insurance? ›

Here's a rundown of 10 factors that could impact your home insurance costs.
  • Your Location. ...
  • The Size of Your Home. ...
  • The Condition of Your Home. ...
  • If You Own or Finance Your Home. ...
  • Your Level of Coverage. ...
  • Your Deductible. ...
  • Previous Homeowners Insurance Claims. ...
  • The Cost of Materials and Construction.
Jan 13, 2023

What damages a house the most? ›

To help keep your home, your valuables and your family safe, you will want to take steps to protect them.
  • Danger #1: Water Damage. ...
  • Danger #2: Weather-Related Roof/Flashing Damage. ...
  • Danger #3: Frozen Pipe Damage. ...
  • Danger #4: Theft. ...
  • Danger #5: Fire.

How to negotiate a homeowners insurance claim? ›

When negotiating with the adjuster, be prepared to advocate for yourself. Be polite and professional, but don't be afraid to push back if you think the settlement offer is too low. Provide evidence to support your position, and be willing to compromise to reach a mutually acceptable agreement.

What is the most expensive insurance ever? ›

We've set a new Guinness World Record for the most valuable life insurance policy ever sold, worth US$250 million. Issued and fully underwritten by HSBC Life, our insurance business in Hong Kong, it was taken out by an individual customer earlier this year.

What is the most expensive insurance of all time? ›

The Guinness record holder: The most valuable life insurance policy ever sold, according to Guinness World Records, is valued at a total of $201 million, on the life of a well-known U.S. billionaire who resides in the Silicon Valley area of California and is actively known in the technology space.

Who is the number 1 home insurance company in America? ›

State Farm is not only the most popular insurer overall — it is the top home insurance company in 39 states and Washington, D.C..

How much does the average person spend on home insurance? ›

How much is home insurance in your state?
StateAverage annual costAverage monthly cost
California$1,250$104
Colorado$3,820$318
Connecticut$1,575$131
Delaware$860$72
48 more rows
Apr 1, 2024

Why did my homeowners insurance go up 2024? ›

Rising Material Costs

Material goods for new residential construction rose 14.3%. Lumber and wood products went up 6.2%. Asphalt roofing materials grew 14.5%. As building costs go up, so does the cost to repair or replace homes damaged by covered losses.

What are the cons of homeowners insurance? ›

Cons of Home Insurance:
  • Cost: One of the primary drawbacks is the cost of home insurance. ...
  • Deductibles: Home insurance policies often come with deductibles, which means you need to pay a certain amount out of pocket before the insurance coverage kicks in.
Oct 12, 2023

Does age affect your home insurance? ›

Home's age and condition

The age and condition of your home can significantly affect your premium. It boils down to risk: For example, a newer roof provides better protection for your home against the elements than an older roof.

What five 5 factors play a role in the cost of home insurance? ›

  • The location of your home. Home location is one of the biggest factors that insurers use to determine homeowners insurance premiums. ...
  • The replacement cost of your home. ...
  • Your policy deductible. ...
  • The condition of your roof. ...
  • Your dog's breed. ...
  • Your claims history. ...
  • The age of your home. ...
  • A home renovation or remodeling project.
Oct 20, 2023

What is the most important thing in homeowners insurance? ›

Make sure you're covered for the right amount – your home insurance policy should cover the full value of your home in case of damage or destruction. When it comes to home insurance, you want to make sure you're getting the right amount of coverage.

What is typically the most common damage claim? ›

Wind and Hail

As the most frequent causes of filed homeowners insurance claims, wind and hail account for 45.5% of claims.

Which insurance has highest claim? ›

On this adjusted basis in 2022 Resolution Life/AMP had the highest number of claims disputes for all types of insurance including Life, TPD, Trauma and Income Protection policies.

What is a high cost claim? ›

This group, known as high-cost claimants (or those whose claims cost $50,000 or more per year), remains the largest driver of health care expenses. Image Description.

What are the majority of homeowner's insurance claims the result of? ›

The vast majority of homeowners insurance claims are for property damage, not liability claims. As a homeowner, this means the coverage will help you pay for expensive repairs after unexpected damage.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Greg Kuvalis

Last Updated:

Views: 6770

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Greg Kuvalis

Birthday: 1996-12-20

Address: 53157 Trantow Inlet, Townemouth, FL 92564-0267

Phone: +68218650356656

Job: IT Representative

Hobby: Knitting, Amateur radio, Skiing, Running, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Greg Kuvalis, I am a witty, spotless, beautiful, charming, delightful, thankful, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.